Most calls from this height come down to two things: something froze, or the well is sending material the tank was never meant to hold.
What the cold did
A split rarely announces itself. Ice opens a seam or a fitting overnight, and the water appears when the weather eases, so the puddle is late evidence. Thawing with a flame is how a repairable line becomes a fire risk; gentle warmth and dry electrics are the rule. A tank or exchanger that cracked is not a repair job.
What the well did
Grit settles on the tank floor and holds heat away from the water. It wears at elements and corrodes the base from the inside. Flushing removes what has arrived; a filter ahead of the unit stops more from following.
What the flame says
A yellow, lazy flame or soot at the flue is a combustion fault: air, burner or venting. It is diagnosed as a set rather than guessed at.
What is worth repairing
Elements, thermostats, valves, igniters, filters, controls. Age alone does not condemn a tank; the condition of the steel does.
What is not
A weeping shell, a base rusted through, a cracked exchanger. Those are described on the replacement page. Water on the move starts at emergency.