Replacement in Hollywood is a scheduling problem as much as a plumbing one. The appliance is straightforward; the building around it is not.
The signals that decide it
A tank leaking at the shell, a rusted base, water that stays discoloured after a flush, or a unit that has needed several repairs in a short time. A sound tank with a failed part is still a repair, whatever its age.
Like-for-like or change
Like-for-like keeps the venting class, the gas branch and the closet as they are, which is why it is the cheaper and faster option in a building.
A different type can mean a new vent route, more gas capacity, a condensate pump and a closet alteration. That is worth doing where the old unit was undersized or where space is the constraint, but it is a planned project rather than a swap.
A second unit is sometimes the answer where demand has grown: a converted unit, an added bathroom, or a back house that was never given its own heater.
What the day involves
Drain the old unit, disconnect water and fuel, remove it by the agreed route, set and connect the new one, vent it, brace it, fill and purge, test, and leave the area as it was found. The permit inspection is arranged separately.
In a building, that sequence also includes coordinating the shut-off so the fewest units are affected, protecting common areas, and confirming who has keys or access.
The permit and the strapping
California requires a permit for installation and replacement, and storage water heaters must be anchored against seismic movement. In the city the permit comes from the Department of Building and Safety, and the inspection is where venting, clearances and strapping get checked.
Old buildings, old surprises
Undersized gas branches, valves that will not reseal, closet framing that will not take a larger unit, and venting shared with another appliance. None of these is unusual in older Los Angeles buildings, and each changes the scope once the unit is out. Planning for one of them is cheaper than being surprised by it.
Timing
A working unit near the end of its range is best replaced on a chosen day, with the permit arranged and residents notified. A failure makes the same work urgent, with water on the floor and no hot water in the building. The emergency page covers the shutdown if that has happened.