The old unit is the best evidence available. How it failed, how long it lasted and what it was connected to tell you what the replacement has to do differently.
What the failure says
A shell that rusted through at the base points at sediment and moisture. A split after a cold night points at where the unit sits. Repeated part failures point at a tank at the end of its life rather than at bad luck. Each answer changes what gets installed.
Matching what works
If the flue, fuel and position are sound and demand has not changed, the least disruptive replacement is the same type in the same place. It keeps the venting class and avoids reworking the closet.
Changing what does not
If the old unit sat in a space that freezes, moving it or protecting it is part of the job. If it was undersized, the replacement is sized from the fixtures. If the water carries grit, a filter goes in ahead of the new tank.
The move
The tank is emptied before it is moved, and the route usually decides how long that takes: a drive a truck cannot turn in, a gate, a flight of steps. Ask about access when booking, because it is the part hardest to change on the day.
Water worth keeping
Where the house draws from a well, every drip is water that had to be pumped. A relief valve that weeps or a tank that seeps gets dealt with in the same visit rather than left for a return trip.
Inspection
An inspector from the county looks at the flue, the clearances, where the relief valve discharges and how the tank is braced before the job is closed.
The installation page sets out a new site in detail, and the maintenance page covers protecting this unit.